
Read Time: 5 Minutes
Sales says the leads are bad.
Marketing says sales never follows up.
And the CEO ends up as the referee... every single week.
Short answer: Put your marketing leader on the same comp plan as your sales leader. Pay both on one number, like bookings or new revenue, and review it together every week. When both teams win or lose on the same quarter, the blame stops and you can see a miss coming a month early.
This one comes from my podcast with Lou Shipley. He was CEO of 3 software companies, sits on company boards, and teaches founders at Harvard Business School. He also co-wrote the book Unlikely Entrepreneurs.
Why do sales and marketing keep blaming each other?
Because they get paid on different things. Marketing gets judged on leads, clicks, or content. Sales gets judged on closed deals. So when the quarter goes badly, each side can point at the other and be partly right. Nobody owns the full number, so the fight never ends on its own. It lands on the CEO's desk.
Lou lived this. He failed to fix it 2 times as a CEO.
"I ended up being as a CEO the referee between the two functions."
His warning for any CEO in the same spot:
"if you don't solve this problem, you as a CEO become the primary bottleneck"
And don't wait for the teams to sort it out. In Lou's words, "people will never really resolve it themselves and they'll always blame the other one for either their failings."
What is marketing's job at a $3M to $40M company?
To help sales close deals. At this size, that means leads that turn into revenue, so reps can hit quota. Your board and investors judge you on growth. Marketing should be judged on the same thing. Brand work can wait until you're much bigger.
Lou was blunt about it:
"my personal opinion is marketing's job in a company that size is sales."
He sees a lot of new marketing hires start in the wrong place. "I think a lot of marketing people come in and even in these smaller companies are like, I'm gonna do branding or I'm gonna do this or that."
His take: "But what really matters is sales."
Big brands are different. "Now once you get to be, marketing at a company like Coca Cola or something like that, then that's a totally different thing where brand is everything." But for you? "Your smaller company, it's all about sales."
How do you put marketing on the same comp plan as sales?
Tie the marketing leader's bonus to the same quarterly number as the sales leader. If sales makes the quarter, marketing does just as well. If sales misses, marketing misses too. Then agree on what a qualified lead is, write it down, and look at the numbers together every week. It takes about 30 minutes to set up.
At Black Duck Software, Lou put his marketing VP on the same comp plan as his head of sales. After that, "his whole organization was focused on generating leads that turned into sales."
The bonus was not for busy work. "it wasn't write a case study and get it published and get a bonus. It was like, did we make our number?"
Do this today (30 minutes):
- Pick 1 number both teams get paid on. Bookings or new revenue, not leads or clicks.
- Pick 2 numbers that lead to it, like qualified leads and new pipeline.
- Agree on what counts as a qualified lead. Write it down.
- Tie marketing's bonus to the same quarterly number as sales.
- Review all 3 numbers together, every week.
If you run Salesforce, build one report with all 3 numbers. Both leaders look at the same report. No side gets its own version of the truth.
How does a shared number help you forecast the quarter?
When both teams chase the same number, you watch the same early signs. If qualified leads come in at the pace you need, you know the deals will follow. Lou's team got to the point where they knew a month before the quarter ended if they would hit the number. No more hoping a big deal lands.
Here's how Lou put it:
"we'd know a month before the end of the quarter if we were gonna make our number or not."
Before that, he was hoping a deal would land at the end of the quarter. It cost him. "I got actually got fired as a software CEO for this of hoping a deal comes in and it doesn't and you miss the quarter."
Once both teams were on one plan, things changed. "It became a joint goal and it wasn't a rivalry, it was a joint effort."
So ask one question 30 days before the quarter ends: based on what we have, will we hit it? If nobody can answer, start with the 3 numbers above.
What if your marketing leader doesn't want this?
Then they may not be the right fit for a company your size. Be clear when you hire. Tell them the company is judged on bookings and revenue growth, and their pay will be tied to that. Some great marketers want to build a brand first. That's fine. They just belong at a bigger company.
Lou says to set this up in the hiring talk. Tell them "the way we as a company are evaluated at this stage is through bookings or revenue growth or customer expansion, that kind of thing."
And if a marketer won't sign up for it? "some marketing people won't want to join a company like that, which is fine. You know, let them go."
Who he wants instead: "I just want the people that just want to grow and do the hard work of getting people to come in and buy your product."
One more thing. It took Lou years and the right people. "You need the right maturity in your leadership team."
Should the founder still be part of sales?
Yes, early on. Lou tells founders to close their first 15 to 20 customers themselves. That's how you learn your sales cycle, your buyer, and what a good lead looks like. You need that to set a fair shared number for sales and marketing later. Then hand it off to leaders who are better at it than you.
His advice to the founders he works with: "close the first fifteen or twenty customers yourself"
More on this: How do we design a sales comp plan that gets reps to sell the right deals?, Should we make marketing budget decisions off our attribution model?, and 3 reasons your leads don't convert
Bottom line
Two teams on two comp plans will fight. One team on one number won't.
Pick the number. Define a qualified lead. Tie both bonuses to the quarter. Look at it together every week.
Frequently asked questions
Should marketing have a revenue quota?
At a $3M to $40M company, tie the marketing leader's bonus to the same revenue or bookings number as sales. Lou did this at Black Duck Software. If the company made the quarter, marketing did just as well as sales.
What number should sales and marketing share?
Use 1 number both teams get paid on, like bookings or new revenue. Then track 2 numbers that lead to it, like qualified leads and new pipeline. Don't pay marketing on leads or clicks alone.
How do we agree on what a qualified lead is?
Get the heads of sales and marketing in one room and write the rule down. Put it in your CRM so every lead gets judged the same way. Change it only when both leaders agree.
When does brand marketing matter more than leads?
When you're a much bigger company. Lou said brand is everything at a company like Coca Cola. At a smaller company, he said it's all about sales.
How early can we tell if we'll miss the quarter?
With a shared number and weekly reviews, Lou's team knew about a month before the quarter ended. Ask 30 days out: based on what we have, will we hit it?
Want more of this? The Simply Scale newsletter drops every week: Subscribe here
Need help with Salesforce? Book a call: https://calendly.com/jordan-gosimplyscale/30min?utm_source=blog&utm_campaign=sales-marketing-same-comp-plan
